Seltzer Vs Sparkling Water: Differences, Benefits, And Myths

Water is the most hydrating drink on the planet, but sometimes, we crave a little more excitement. Enter seltzer vs sparkling water — both fizzy, both refreshing, but not quite the same. If you've ever wondered about their differences, benefits, and common myths, you're in the right place.

 

The Popularity Of Carbonated Water

Fact: 64% of consumers prefer drinking bottled still water, with 38% of them inclining towards sparkling water.

Also a fact: The rapid growth of seltzers is a picked-up fad touted by celebrities and influencers, and the seltzer industry is projected to reach $93 billion by 2030.

Now that we’ve established the popularity of both seltzer and sparkling water, let’s address the elephant in the room — seltzer vs sparkling water, or are they the same?

Can they appear the same? Sure.

But are they? Not quite.

While they may look identical, their origins, mineral content, and carbonation methods set them apart. Let’s break it down on a wider scale so you can make an informed choice.


Sparkling Water vs. Seltzer vs. Soda Water vs. Club Soda

Not all carbonated waters are created equal, and you’ve probably encountered other fizzy water terms outside sparkling water vs seltzer, like soda water and club soda. What are they, and what’s the difference?

Some occur naturally, while others are entirely man-made. Some have minerals that subtly alter their taste, while others are completely neutral. Here’s a summary below.

Cue the sigh of relief — we don’t have to interchange these terms anymore or blink in confusion when anybody asks us the difference.

The truth is, each type of carbonated water serves a different purpose, whether it's for pure refreshment, mixing with drinks, or adding a hint of minerals to your hydration routine.

Now that we’ve debunked the others, let’s hone in on seltzer vs sparkling water.


What Is Sparkling Water?

Understanding what is sparkling water sounds like a complicated task, but it’s quite simple. Sparkling water comes from naturally carbonated sources like underground springs or be made by adding carbon dioxide (CO2) to still water. Some brands bottle it straight from the source, while others enhance it with CO2.

Rich in minerals such as potassium, magnesium, sodium, and bicarbonate, it offers a subtly salty and mineral-like taste.

Common Misconception: Many people confuse sparkling water with seltzer, but they’re different. Sparkling water contains natural minerals, while seltzer is simply carbonated water without minerals.

 

What Is Seltzer?

Seltzer is simply plain water that has been artificially carbonated by injecting carbon dioxide (CO2) into still water. Unlike sparkling water, which may contain natural minerals from its source, seltzer is completely free of minerals, giving it a clean, crisp, and neutral taste.

Because of its lack of minerals and distinct flavor, seltzer is an extremely versatile beverage. It’s a popular choice for those who want carbonation without any added taste, making it a refreshing stand-alone drink. It’s also a go-to mixer for cocktails and mocktails — just like sparkling water.

So, let’s u-turn back to the question at hand — Is seltzer water the same as sparkling water? No, and here’s why:

Let’s get into the details.


Seltzer Vs Sparkling Water: Key Differences

At first glance, seltzer and sparkling water might seem identical, but their differences go beyond just the name. From how they’re made to how they taste and what they pair best with, each type of carbonated water has unique characteristics.

 

1. Source of Carbonation

The biggest distinction between seltzer and sparkling water is how they get their fizz:

  • Sparkling Water: Comes from natural sources such as underground springs or wells, where the water is naturally infused with carbon dioxide. However, some brands may enhance the carbonation by adding extra CO2 during the bottling process.

  • Seltzer: Is artificially carbonated by injecting CO2 into still water. It doesn’t originate from a natural source and has no inherent carbonation before processing.

Because of this difference, sparkling water has a more delicate and naturally occurring carbonation, while seltzer tends to have a sharper, more intense fizz that mimics the texture of soda.

 

2. Mineral Content & Taste

Minerals play a big role in how water tastes, and this is where sparkling water and seltzer diverge significantly:

  • Sparkling Water: Contains naturally occurring minerals like magnesium, calcium, potassium, and sodium, which influence its slightly salty, mineral-rich taste. Since it comes from a natural source, the mineral content varies depending on the brand and region.

  • Seltzer: Has no minerals, which results in a pure, crisp, and neutral taste. This makes it a great choice for people who prefer carbonation without any minerals.

If you enjoy a more complex, subtly flavored carbonated drink, sparkling water is the way to go. If you prefer a completely neutral and refreshing taste, seltzer is your best bet.

 

3. Mouthfeel & Carbonation Intensity

The difference in carbonation sources also affects the mouthfeel of each drink:

  • Sparkling Water: Often has smaller, smoother bubbles that create a more natural, soft, and lingering fizz.

  • Seltzer: Typically has larger, more aggressive bubbles that deliver a sharp, crisp, and fizzy kick similar to soda.

If you like a gentler, more refined fizz, sparkling water will be more enjoyable. If you want a punchier, soda-like bite, seltzer is a better choice.

 

4. Common Uses & Pairings

While both seltzer and sparkling water are refreshing on their own, they each serve slightly different purposes:

  • Sparkling Water: Often enjoyed plain as a sophisticated alternative to still water. It pairs well with meals, especially rich foods, since the slight minerality can enhance flavors. Some people also use it to make mocktails or light cocktails.

  • Seltzer: A common mixer for cocktails and mocktails, thanks to its neutral taste and sharper carbonation. It’s commonly used in drinks like spritzers or as a base for homemade flavored waters.

Because seltzer lacks minerals, it’s often flavored with natural fruit essences or used as a zero-calorie alternative to sodas. Many people wonder, “is seltzer water bad for you?” precisely for this reason — stay away from seltzer with added sugars. Fruit essences? Go ahead!

If taste is the priority, flavored seltzer works wonders. If health is the focus, nothing beats natural sparkling water.

Now that we’ve established how different they are — let’s tackle the thing they have in common: carbonation.


Is Carbonated Water Bad for You?

Many people worry that carbonated water might harm their health, causing issues like bone loss, tooth decay, Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), or even weight gain.

But how much of this is true? Let’s bust some myths.

1. Does Carbonation Affect Bone Health?

  • A common myth is that all carbonated drinks weaken bones.

  • Fact: Colas (which contain phosphoric acid) have been linked to lower bone density, but plain carbonated water does not have the same effect.

  • Studies show that non-cola carbonated drinks, like seltzer and sparkling water, do not negatively impact bone health.

2. Does Carbonated Water Erode Tooth Enamel?

  • The concern about carbonated water and tooth decay comes from its slightly acidic nature.

  • Fact: Plain sparkling water is far less acidic than soda or fruit juice and is unlikely to cause significant enamel damage.

  • Studies show that while carbonation alone isn’t harmful, adding citric acid or sweeteners (as found in flavored seltzers and sodas) can increase enamel erosion.

  • To protect your teeth, drink carbonated water, specifically flavored seltzer, with a straw to minimize contact with your enamel.

3. Can Carbonation Cause IBS or Digestive Issues?

  • People with IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome) or sensitive stomachs sometimes experience bloating or gas from fizzy drinks.

  • Fact: Carbonated water does not cause IBS, but the gas from carbonation can trigger bloating or discomfort in those who are already prone to digestive issues.

  • If you have IBS, it may be best to consume carbonated beverages in moderation and observe how your body reacts.

4. Is Fizzy Water Fattening?

  • Plain carbonated water contains zero sugar, zero calories, and zero fat — so it won’t make you gain weight.

  • However, flavored or sweetened varieties (like tonic water) may contain added sugars, which can contribute to weight gain.

  • Some research suggests carbonation can trigger ghrelin (the hunger hormone), which may increase appetite. If you’re watching your weight, opt for unsweetened sparkling water.

  • To understand in depth the relationship between carbonated water and weight gain, check out this helpful resource.

The Verdict

For most people, plain carbonated water is completely safe and can even encourage better hydration.

The only concerns arise with flavored carbonated water, which may contain acids or sugars that impact dental health and metabolism. If you have IBS or a sensitive stomach, monitor your intake to see how your body responds.

Otherwise, enjoy your fizzy water guilt-free.


Environmental Impact of Seltzer vs Sparkling Water

With growing awareness of sustainability, it’s worth considering the environmental impact of your choice.

  • Bottled Sparkling Water often comes from natural sources and is packaged in plastic or glass bottles, contributing to waste and carbon emissions from transportation. Not to mention, it contains microplastics.

  • Canned Seltzer is generally lighter to transport, but aluminum production has its own environmental footprint.

  • Home Carbonation Systems (like Carbon8) offer the most sustainable solution, reducing plastic waste and transportation emissions by allowing you to carbonate water at home.

If sustainability is a key factor in your decision, a home carbonator is the best way to enjoy fizzy water without the environmental cost of single-use bottles and cans.


Seltzer vs Sparkling Water: Which One Should You Choose?

So, now that you know the differences, how do you pick the best choice for you? It all comes down to taste, texture, and how you plan to enjoy it.

  • If you love a mineral-rich, naturally carbonated fizz, go for sparkling water. It has a slightly complex taste thanks to the natural minerals, making it a great, healthy standalone drink. Some people say it feels more “elevated” or “luxurious.” Think of it as the fine wine of carbonated water.

  • If you prefer a clean, crisp, and neutral taste, seltzer is your best bet. With no added minerals, it’s the ultimate blank canvas — perfect for mixing with cocktails, adding a splash of juice, or simply enjoying as a refreshing drink.

And if you ever find yourself wondering, “Wait, is this club soda? Or seltzer? Or sparkling water?” — you’re not alone. The labels can be confusing, but now you have the knowledge to sip smarter.

At the end of the day, both seltzer and sparkling water keep you hydrated and add a little excitement to your water routine. So whether you like the smooth minerality of sparkling water or the pure crispness of seltzer, the best choice is simply the one you enjoy the most.

 

How Carbon8 Gives You Sparkling Water At Its Finest

The Carbon8 Sparkling Water Maker redefines sparkling water at its finest, combining purity, convenience, and great taste — all from the comfort of your home.

  • Instant, Effortless Carbonation – Patented technology infuses water with CO2 instantly, creating a continuous stream of crisp, refreshing sparkling water.

  • One-Touch Simplicity – No cartridges, no waiting. Just press a button for pure convenience.

  • Chlorine-Free, Mineral-Rich Water – The filter removes chlorine and adds essential minerals found in natural spring water. So you can safely carbonate tap water, ultimately reducing plastic waste.

  • UV Purification – Built-in UV light ensures every sip is fresh, pure, and free from contaminants.

  • Naturally Better Flavor – Every purchase comes with True Citrus flavor packets — sugar-free, non-GMO, and made from real fruit, for a clean, refreshing taste.

With Carbon8, you get more than just sparkling water. You get the cleanest, freshest hydration, every time, endlessly.

 

Seltzer vs Sparkling Water: Bottom Line

Both seltzer and sparkling water bring the fizz, but the real difference lies in the details. If you love a crisp, clean taste, seltzer is your go-to. If you prefer a subtly mineral, naturally carbonated sip, sparkling water is the better pick.

No matter your choice, both are refreshing, hydrating, and completely guilt-free, so drink up and enjoy the sparkle!

Back to News